1. Home
  2. Best Fiber Bars
  3. Special K Protein Bars Review

Special K Protein Bars Review

Remy
Remy has reviewed over 100 protein bars. He's the founder of Human Food Bar.

5 Reasons Special K Protein Bars Aren’t So Special (#3 is Gut-Wrenching)

Comparison graphic detailing Special K Protein Bars

Kellogg’s wants you to believe their Special K Protein Bars are a guilt-free, healthy snack. But what if I told you they’re hiding a dirty little secret behind that excessively shiny wrapper? Honestly, it’s just buzzwords and BS. Just because Kellogg’s adds the words “protein” and “meal replacement” to their packaging doesn’t mean this bar is healthy. What’s inside is basically a nutritional nightmare.

The Special K Protein Bar is a dinosaur, clinging to dated ingredients that were never good—and now we know they’re bad.

Macros: 180 calories, 6g fat, 12g protein, 9g sugar (includes 9g added sugars!), 6g fiber, 15g net carbs

1. Marketing vs. Reality: Big Food’s False Promises

Kellogg’s has a history of misleading claims. Most recently, its CEO got into hot water for telling struggling Americans to eat cereal for dinner—in essence, “let them eat Frosted Flakes.”

The CEO of Kellogg is happy to say that more people are eating cereal for dinner. In fact, the company is leaning into it and intentionally advertising about cereal as a dinner meal for cash-strapped families.
by iniamatotalpieceofshit

As if that’s not tone-deaf enough, their so-called “heart-healthy” cereals are loaded with sugar. And their “whole grain” snacks are mostly just refined flour. Now, they’re using the same tactics to promote their protein bars as “meal replacements” despite relying on a formula that’s stuck in the past. Don’t get me wrong, protein is essential for a healthy diet. But when it comes from highly processed sources like soy protein isolate (more on that later), it’s hardly a health food. As consumers, we have the power to vote with our wallets. Let’s choose to support brands that are committed to real, whole-food ingredients (not some bait-and-switch routine like Special K’s Strawberry protein bar), not the ones that try to trick us with outdated recipes and clever marketing.

Bought these protein bars because I love strawberries…only to find out it doesn’t actually contain strawberries. byu/EvilishMystic inmildlyinfuriating

 

2. Not-So-Special Ingredients

One look at the ingredients and you know you’ll need to brace yourself for the nutritional horror show that’s inside Special K Protein Bars:

The Problem with Soy Protein Isolate

Right out of the gate, you’re hit with soy protein isolate. This highly processed protein source is often derived from genetically modified soybeans. It’s cheap and convenient for manufacturers, but it lacks the nutritional value of whole-food protein sources. According to Lauren Manaker, MS, RDN, LD, CLEC, CPT, “This process of isolation can also strip away some of the other nutritional benefits found in whole soy products, such as fiber and minerals.”

Due to its low fiber content and potential for antinutrient presence, it can cause digestive problems like gas, bloating, and constipation for some folks.

And if you thought Special K Bars were unhealthy, read our review, which proves that Supergut Protein Bars are not healthy either.

Sugar Overload: Corn Syrup’s Impact

Next up is corn syrup, which is a major contributor to inflammation and blood sugar spikes, which can lead to a host of health problems like diabetes, obesity, heart disease, and fatty liver disease. “Chronic overconsumption of high fructose corn syrup causes an increase in fat production and worsens insulin sensitivity,” says Jennifer Feda, Clinical Nutrition Manager at the Hospital of Central Connecticut in New Britain.

List of ingredients in Special K Chocolate Peanut Butter Protein Bars

Digestive Disaster: The Sugar Alcohol Trio

Let’s get into the sugar alcohols this nightmare contains. We’re talking maltitol, sorbitol, and steviol glycosides. “Consuming a lot of sugar alcohols can lead to flatulence, bloating, abdominal pain, and diarrhea, especially if you have underlying gastrointestinal conditions like irritable bowel syndrome or inflammatory bowel disease,” says Dr. William Chey, a gastroenterologist and professor of medicine at Michigan Medicine.

Inflammatory Oils: A Recipe for Imbalance

Finally, don’t get me started on the oils in these bars. You’re looking at vegetable oils like soybean, palm, and palm kernel oil. All of these pro-inflammatory oils are high in omega-6 fatty acids, which can contribute to chronic inflammation and disrupt your omega-3 to omega-6 ratio. “These omega-6 fatty acids are pushing out the important omega-3 fatty acids that keep the brain healthy”, according to Professor John Stein, emeritus professor of neuroscience at Oxford University.

3. The Macro Myth: Is This Bar Really “Healthy?”

Don’t let the macronutrients fool you. While the numbers on the label might seem passable at first glance, a deeper dive reveals a nutritional disaster in disguise.

Sure, these bars boast 12 grams of protein, but that’s hardly a saving grace when you consider the onslaught of unhealthy, outdated ingredients and the sugar overload it delivers. It’s like trying to justify a gourmet meal because it has a sprinkle of truffle oil, while ignoring the fact that it’s mostly made of expired canned goods. You’d be far better off getting your protein from whole-food sources like lean meats, fish, beans, or a modern protein bar that actually uses high-quality ingredients (learn more below).

Speaking of sugar, this bar is anything but shy on the sweet stuff. A whopping 9 grams of added sugar can be found in the Special K Chocolatey Chip Cookie Dough Protein Meal Bar, and that’s definitely enough to make your dentist cringe. That’s nearly a tablespoon of pure sugar! For a snack that claims to be “healthy,” that’s an absolute betrayal.

Screenshot of Amazon customer review questioning whether the Special K bar is a candy or protein bar.And don’t even get me started on the fiber. While the 7 grams found in the Brownie Batter Protein Meal Bars might seem like a positive, it’s mostly derived from polydextrose, a synthetic filler with questionable benefits. In fact, some studies suggest this cheap bulking agent can actually harm your gut health. So much for a “guilt-free” snack.

4. The Taste Test: A Gritty Disappointment

I tried the Chocolate Peanut Butter bar and was hoping it might not taste as bad as the ingredients inside. But I was greeted with an unpleasant, gritty texture and an artificial flavor that left a bad taste in my mouth (literally).

And I’m not alone. I found other online reviews with many customers complaining about the bar’s chalky consistency and overly sweet taste.

Screenshot of customer review complaining that the Special K Protein Meal Bar has a gritty and sandy texture.And one reviewer found it so disgusting he said, “It tastes like powdered breakfast cancer.” Ouch!

@spieo Do better K. . . . #ridefinds #foraging #biketok #cycling #commuterlife #bikelife #cyclist #nutritiontips #proteinbars #specialk ♬ Shempi – Ratatat

5. Cheap Doesn’t Mean Good: Prioritizing Quality Over Cost

Sure, Special K bars are super cheap. I picked up a box of 6 at my local grocery store for under 7 bucks. But as the saying goes, you get what you pay for. Investing in high-quality, nutrient-dense snacks that nourish your body is an investment in your long-term health. Your gut (and taste buds) will thank you.

Looking for other High Fiber Protein Bars? Read our Supergut Bar review for an alternative to Special K Bars.

 

Our Review

Closeup photo of packaging showing Special K Chocolate Peanut Butter Protein Meal Bar with 12g of protein
Special K Protein Meal Bars Review
The Takeaway
The Special K Protein Bar is a prime example of how misleading marketing can disguise a nutritional dud. It’s filled with a laundry list of cheap, outdated, and potentially harmful ingredients like soy protein isolate, corn syrup, and sugar alcohols. The taste and texture leave much to be desired. Like a dinosaur on its last legs, the Special K Protein Bar is a lumbering reminder of a time when we were willing to sacrifice taste and health for convenience.
Taste and Texture
Nutrition Macros
Fiber Quality
Ingredients
Value
Pros
Cheap
Cons
Tastes terrible
High sugar alcohols
Bad fiber quality
1

Why You Deserve More Than a “Fake Food” Protein Bar

Many bars on the market, even those boasting low net carbs and high protein, often mask a less appealing reality. They rely on processed ingredients, gut-wrecking sugar substitutes, and a nutritional profile that’s closer to candy than a wholesome snack. Special K, unfortunately, falls squarely into this category.

At Human Food Bar, we believe in a different approach. We’ve created a plant-based bar packed with prebiotic fiber and resistant starch to nourish your microbiome and support optimal health.

Unlike Special K, our bar is inspired by the fiber-rich diets of our hunter-gatherer ancestors. We’ve meticulously chosen ingredients like tiger nuts, chicory root, and green banana flour to deliver a bar that’s not only delicious but genuinely beneficial for your gut and overall well-being.

Don’t settle for outdated formulas and empty promises. Choose a protein bar that truly nourishes your body. Try Human Food Bar today and experience the difference real, whole-food ingredients can make.

FAQs

Are Special K bars actually healthy?

No, despite their marketing claims, Special K Protein Bars are not a healthy snack option. This is due to their processed ingredients, high sugar content, and questionable nutritional value.

What are the worst ingredients in Special K Protein Bars?

Some of the worst offenders include soy protein isolate, maltitol, corn syrup, added sugars, and vegetable oils.

Are Special K bars keto-friendly?

No, with 8 grams of sugar per bar, Special K Protein Bars are not suitable for a ketogenic diet.

Are Special K bars high in carbs?

While they contain 7 grams of fiber, the overall carb content is relatively high due to the added sugars and fillers.

Founder
Remy is the founder of Human Food Bar. A health and wellness enthusiast based in Berkeley, California with a deep interest in dietary nutrition, he's well versed in the Plant Paradox, Keto, Paleo and Vegan diets. He has a borderline obsession with nutrition bars that eventually gave birth to the Human Food Bar. In his free time he likes to blog, cook, mixologize, garden and mountain bike.
follow me
Registered Dietitian Nutritionist, Nutritional Synergy
Total Posts: 0
Kathy is a Registered Dietitian Nutritionist with a Master of Science degree from Michigan State University in Human Nutrition. She's been a Registered Dietitian for 32 years serving in all capacities of my profession from clinical nutrition to public health and education. She's passionate about helping people change their lives for the better using medical nutrition therapy and in the art and practice of writing about all aspects of functional and integrative nutrition.
×
Founder
Remy is the founder of Human Food Bar. A health and wellness enthusiast based in Berkeley, California with a deep interest in dietary nutrition, he's well versed in the Plant Paradox, Keto, Paleo and Vegan diets. He has a borderline obsession with nutrition bars that eventually gave birth to the Human Food Bar. In his free time he likes to blog, cook, mixologize, garden and mountain bike.

Pin It on Pinterest